結局、リバタリアンは自由移民制度に賛成すべきなのか、どうなのか

Hans-Hermann Hoppe's views about immigration, which do not cast libertarianism as requiring open borders, have been controversial within the wider libertarian movement. Walter Block offered arguments against Hoppe's immigration position in a 1999 article, "A Libertarian Case for Free Immigration."

Hoppe has countered his opponents by commenting on their opinions in footnote 23 to Natural Order, the State, and the Immigration Problem (PDF):

A second motive for the open border enthusiasm among contemporary left-libertarians is their egalitarianism. They were initially drawn to libertarianism as juveniles because of its "antiauthoritarianism" (trust no authority) and seeming "tolerance," in particular toward "alternative" ― non-bourgeois ― lifestyles. As adults, they have been arrested in this phase of mental development. They express special "sensitivity" in every manner of discrimination and are not inhibited in using the power of the central state to impose non-discrimination or "civil rights" statutes on society. Consequently, by prohibiting other property owners from discrimination as they see fit, they are allowed to live at others' expense. They can indulge in their "alternative" lifestyle without having to pay the "normal" price for such conduct, i.e., discrimination and exclusion. To legitimize this course of action, they insist that one lifestyle is as good and acceptable as another. This leads first to multiculturalism, then to cultural relativism, and finally to "open borders."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans-Hermann_Hoppe

アナルコキャピタリスト社会、すなわち国家のない完全な私有財産制では、財産の私的所有者にすべての権限が与えられるのであり、どんな差別・排除をすることも認められるわけである。（参考：PRIVATOPIA - 私的所有は差別を意味する）

（民主主義国家の為政者は、君主制国家の為政者と違って、才能があり生産的な市民の国外流出を気にかけないはずであるへ続く）


◆関連記事

移民受け入れの是非
http://anacap.jugem.jp/?eid=62

移民受け入れの是非2
http://anacap.jugem.jp/?eid=63

移民受け入れの是非3
http://anacap.jugem.jp/?eid=64

海外移住：一国リバタリアニズムとグローバルなリバタリアニズム
http://anacap.jugem.jp/?eid=131

貿易・移民を強く制限する民間保護機関はあるか？
http://anacap.jugem.jp/?eid=132